Environmentalists Misuse GOP Quote

FactCheck.org

The League of Conservation Voters misuses a quote by a Republican congressman to portray him as “extreme” on climate change.

The environmental group quotes Rep. Rodney Davis in a TV ad as saying “global warming has stopped 16 years ago.” But the Illinois freshman actually said, “They say that global warming has stopped 16 years ago.” He went on to say, “But climate change is real.”

The TV ad, titled “Sixteen Years Ago,” is part of a nearly $2 million ad campaign targeting four Republican members of Congress for their views on climate change. About halfway into the ad, the narrator says, “Congressman Davis is so extreme that he denies climate change science, suggesting” — and then Davis is heard saying — “global warming has stopped 16 years ago.”

On the screen, viewers see “Congressman Davis. ‘Global Warming Stopped 16 Years Ago.’ ”

A video or other embedded content has been hidden. Click here to view it.

That’s not what Davis said. The quote is lifted from an October 2012 radio interview that Davis did on a call-in show with Illinois Public Media during last year’s congressional campaign. Here is a partial transcript of an exchange between Davis and a caller named “Bob” (starts at about the 42:15 mark):

Bob: I have a question about climate change. The scientific consensus about climate change has been strengthening over the last decade. The forecast, which of course depend on what we do, show that the climate of Illinois will become more like Oklahoma and Texas over this century than what we’re used to, and droughts will become more common. I’m just wondering what your plan on dealing with climate change is.

Davis: Ironically, if you listen to recent reports, they say that global warming has stopped 16 years ago –

Bob: That’s absolutely wrong.

Davis: Yeah, I was just about –

Bob: You are absolutely off base –

Davis: Hey, Bob, Bob, I was just about to make a comment that I would love to see more stats than what’s just been reported on a couple stations. But climate change is real. The debate is over whether or not it’s man-made or natural, and what can we do about it. The key is –

Bob: We have a Nobel Prize winner here at the University of Illinois. I suggest you call him up.

Davis: OK. Great.

As the transcript makes clear, Davis said, “They say that global warming has stopped 16 years ago,” but the edited version leaves out the words “they say that.” The fact that Davis made a reference at all to “recent reports” about global warming stopping (reports that had been widely debunked by climate scientists) obviously troubled the caller, who cut off Davis’ response. But Davis did not say he agreed with those who say climate change had stopped, and, in fact, he said “climate change is real,” when given the chance to resume speaking.

He also did not express an opinion in the radio interview on whether climate change is man-made, although he acknowledges that there is a debate about it. So does Davis deny that climate change is caused by human activity? Well, that same month the News-Gazette published a candidate questionnaire, and one of the questions that Davis answered was on climate change:

Question: Do you believe in climate change/global warming, and if so would you vote for legislation that would mandate reductions in levels of global warming pollution by 2020 or 2025?

Davis: Many factors contribute to changes in climate, both man-made and natural. Regardless of your views on global warming, we should all agree that reducing our dependence on foreign oil and cutting air pollution without doing economic harm to our citizens will benefit our national security, environment and public health.

We couldn’t find any instances of Davis denying that climate change exists or that man isn’t at least partially to blame for it. We asked the League of Conservation Voters for such evidence, but the group’s response didn’t include any more information. We also contacted Davis’ congressional office and asked if Davis believes that climate change is caused by man. His spokesman, Andrew Flach, told us: “It is one of the contributing factors, yes, but to what extent is open to debate and further research.”

Flach’s response is no doubt unsatisfactory to those, including the League of Conservation Voters, who want Congress to act immediately on climate change based on the scientific evidence. As we have written before, the National Academy of Sciences published a paper in 2010 that found 97 percent to 98 percent of climate researchers “most actively publishing in the field” agreed that climate change was occurring. And the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change said in a 2007 report that human activity is “very likely” the cause of “most of the observed increase in global average temperatures since the mid-20th century.”

There also is no question that Davis, a Republican, opposes environmental regulations that he views as anti-business — including those aimed at reducing greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming. That, too, rankles the League. The TV ad says Davis “even opposes common sense efforts to reduce carbon pollution.” That’s a reference to an amendment Davis supported earlier this month that would require Congress to approve any regulations to tax carbon emissions. The sponsor of the amendment, Rep. Steve Scalise, said it was in response to President Obama’s climate change speech in which the president proposed bypassing Congress by using his executive powers and taking regulatory steps to reduce the greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming.

We take no position on whether Davis’ views on climate change are “extreme” or if the president has a “common sense” plan. But the League of Conservation Voters went too far when it edited an audio clip of Davis to make it sound as if he said something that he didn’t.

– Eugene Kiely

Update, Aug. 16: We original wrote that we did not receive a response from the League of Conservation Voters. The group did send us an email that wasn’t successfully delivered to our inbox.

 

View Comments (651)

Recommended for You

  • Hurricane-strength winds pummel Europe, four killed

    By Michael Hogan HAMBURG (Reuters) - At least four people were killed on Tuesday when hurricane-force winds lashed northern Europe in one of the most severe storms in years, forcing flights to be canceled and disrupting road, train and marine traffic. The Dutch meteorological office issued a red…

    Reuters
  • United States sets official strategy for Paris climate talks

    By Valerie Volcovici WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The Obama administration on Tuesday published plans to cut greenhouse gas emissions up to 28 percent below 2005 levels by 2025, part of a strategy to generate momentum for a global agreement later this year on combating climate change. The formal…

    Reuters
  • Air and sea traffic disrupted as 120 km winds batter Netherlands

    Spring storms battered the Netherlands with gusts of up to 120 kilometers an hour on Tuesday, causing Amsterdam's Schiphol airport to cancel flights and the closure of two container terminals at the port of Rotterdam. Gale force winds sweeping in from the North Sea disrupted land and marine…

    Reuters
  • Heavy rains trigger flood fears in Kashmir; 17 dead

    By Fayaz Bukhari SRINAGAR, India (Reuters) - Heavy rains and a landslide in the Himalayan region of Kashmir killed 17 people, police said on Tuesday, as Indian authorities continued working to rescue stranded villagers, with unseasonal rains raising fears of flash floods in the mountainous north. …

    Reuters
  • Ocean warming suggests 50 percent chance of El Nino-Australia

    By Colin Packham SYDNEY (Reuters) - Recent warming of the Pacific Ocean may signal an El Nino weather event is forming, the Australian Bureau of Meteorology said on Tuesday. Climate models indicate the central tropical Pacific Ocean is likely to continue to warm, with El Nino thresholds to be…

    Reuters
  • Vanuatu risks long-term food insecurity after monster cyclone: U.N.

    By Alisa Tang BANGKOK (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - The monster cyclone that hit Vanuatu earlier this month wiped out more than 90 percent of the archipelago's crops, putting its people at risk of a secondary emergency and long-term food insecurity, the United Nations warned on Monday. Tropical…

    Reuters
  • Heavy rains trigger flood fears in Kashmir; six dead

    By Fayaz Bukhari SRINAGAR, India (Reuters) - A landslide in the Himalayan region of Kashmir killed six people and left 10 missing, police said on Monday, as unseasonal rains swept India, damaging crops and raising fears of flash floods in the mountainous north. Hundreds of people fled their homes…

    Reuters
  • Harsh weather cripples fishing and tourism on Cameroon's coast

    By Elias Ntungwe Ngalame KRIBI, Cameroon (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - For over 15 years, Raoul Meno has been fishing the waters off the coastal town of Kribi in southern Cameroon. A bout of persistent heavy rains and surging tides this year has made fishing in Kribi increasingly difficult and…

    Reuters
  • Air Canada plane landed short, hit antennas in Halifax accident

    By Mark Blinch HALIFAX, Nova Scotia (Reuters) - An Air Canada plane that suffered heavy damage in an accident in the east coast city of Halifax on Sunday landed short of the runway and hit an antenna array, losing its landing gear, safety officials said. "They touched down 1,100 feet (335 meters)…

    Reuters
  • U.S. to submit plans to fight global warming; most others delay

    By Alister Doyle and Valerie Volcovici OSLO/WASHINGTON - The United States will submit plans for slowing global warming to the United Nations early this week but most governments will miss an informal March 31 deadline, complicating work on a global climate deal due in December. The U.S.…

    Reuters
  • Modi's popularity in rural India punctured by discontent, suicides

    By Mayank Bhardwaj VAIDI, India (Reuters) - Over a dozen debt-laden farmers have committed suicide in recent weeks in India, and discontent in many rural areas against government policies is turning into anger against Prime Minister Narendra Modi less than a year after he swept into office. …

    Reuters
  • Chile desert rains sign of climate change: chief weather scientist

    By Rosalba O'Brien SANTIAGO (Reuters) - The heavy rainfall that battered Chile's usually arid north this week happened because of climate change, a senior meteorologist said, as the region gradually returns to normal after rivers broke banks and villages were cut off. "For Chile, this particular…

    Reuters
  • Mexico unveils national strategy for Paris climate talks

    By Valerie Volcovici WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Mexico on Friday said it will cap its greenhouse gas emissions by 2026, becoming one of the first countries to formally submit its national climate plan to the United Nations ahead of a climate summit in Paris in December. Mexico's Foreign and…

    Reuters
  • Fed must take account of global economy in U.S. outlook: Yellen

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - The Federal Reserve must take the global economy into account when judging the U.S. domestic outlook, Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen said on Friday, noting that a stronger dollar buoyed by weakness abroad may restrain U.S. exports Still, she added, U.S. consumer…

    Reuters
  • In reversal, crash-hit Lufthansa agrees to two-crew in cockpit rule

    Lufthansa said on Friday it would introduce new rules requiring two crew members in cockpits at all times, a swift reversal after its CEO said such a change was not needed despite the crash at its Germanwings subsidiary. The European Union said it would now advise all EU airlines to require two…

    Reuters
  • Sierra Leone capital 'eerily quiet' amid Ebola lockdown

    By Umaru Fofana FREETOWN (Reuters) - The capital of Sierra Leone was "eerily quiet" on Friday at the start of a three-day national lockdown aimed at accelerating the end of an Ebola epidemic in the worst affected country. Liberia has just one known case left and the three countries have set a…

    Reuters
  • Lufthansa to toughen up cockpit rules

    Lufthansa said it will introduce new rules requiring two crew members to be in the cockpit at all times after one of the pilots at its Germanwings unit crashed a plane in the French Alps. Prosecutors believe Andreas Lubitz, 27, locked himself alone in the cockpit of the Airbus A320 on Tuesday and…

    Reuters
  • Poland to charge two Russian officials over Kaczynski plane crash

    Poland said on Friday it would bring charges against two Russian air traffic controllers over a 2010 plane crash which killed then Polish president Lech Kaczynski, a move likely to damage bilateral relations already strained by the Ukraine crisis. Prosecutor Ireneusz Szelag from the District…

    Reuters
  • Drought, warm weather bring 'smog day' memories in California

    By Sharon Bernstein KINGS COUNTY, Calif. (Reuters) - The brown haze over California's San Joaquin Valley breadbasket on some winter days has been an unwelcome reminder of the bad old days, when pollution hung so thickly that people were warned to stay inside. Years of tight environmental rules…

    Reuters
  • India turns to 'satellite god' for crop mapping

    By Ratnajyoti Dutta NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Sher Singh, a farmer from India's desert state of Rajasthan, prays to Varuna, the Hindu god of water, for a bountiful harvest. Prime Minister Narendra Modi wants to promote a "per drop, more crop" approach to farming to make better use of scarce water,…

    Reuters